John Lauer
ENGL 250
Calming the Inner Critic and Getting to Work
By Allegra Goodman
Thought Piece
My Thoughts…
When
writing, what do we focus on? The grammar… the ideas… or what people will think
of it? I believe that the “inner critic” inside of our minds is most influenced
by the overarching eyes that will be looking at our writing. As humans, we have
the natural tendency to care what people think of us. If we stopped caring
about other people’s opinions of us, would the inner critic go away? Or would
we still find fault in our own writing? Longing over every page of and essay or
book, realizing we aren't perfect and there must be something wrong in every
paragraph. The realization is that we will always have the inner critic in our head;
we just have to realize when he is on duty. Can we get him to take more
vacation days per year? Maybe we can, but only if we start thinking about our
writing differently.
Writing
is something that people do. Whether it is for school, a job, or pure enjoyment
we all do it at one point. Some people like writing and love producing works of
art with words. Others, like myself, look at writing as unenjoyable, stupid,
and unneeded if it is purely creative and not used to educate and/or for
betterment of the world. As an engineer, I look at literature in a different
way than other people. But I know writing is important and I know that it is
needed for the world. It is used in so many different ways that it is involved
in everyone’s job or daily life. The reason I mention this is because the way
we look at writing affects how we write and how much the inner critic really affects
us. If we care about our writing, then the inner critic will control us so much
more than if we are writing just because we have to for a class and don’t actually
care about the meaning of our writing. I feel that if you don’t care about your
writing in a class setting where it will be graded, then you don’t care about
your grade and/or the class itself. Which is why in every setting, you should
have the inner critic in your head to some degree. I believe that the bother-some
inner critic is most determined by how confident we are with our own writing. If
we are confident with knowing that not everyone will like our writing, we will
be able block the inner critic more. For me, when I write, I just try to write grammatically
correct and have my ideas in a good order. Writing can’t be perfect because everyone
has a different opinion so I guess in theory, there will always be something
wrong with your paper. Some people can write close to perfect papers, but
writing will always be up for interpretation and you must except that you are writing
for you and for you to be happy with it. The inner critic does help you think
about how your paper will be portrayed and makes you think in a way that will
help you produce writing that will please more people, but don’t let it block
you. Don’t let it keep you from writing what you believe. Freedom of speech was
written in the constitution for a reason. As writers, we owe it to ourselves to
write what we want and be accepted.
In
the end, the inner critic will always be there. Don’t let it get you! Be confident
and know that your writing does not need to be controlled by it. You don’t need
others approvals because writing is free to whatever you want it to be. If you
find yourself getting stuck then it may not be the inner critic. It might just
be writers block and that means you just need a break. Even to someone who doesn't
like writing, even I can enjoy just writing my own thoughts down and knowing
that all writing just needs to be thought provoked and done with a purpose. Even
though I’m an engineer, writing will be a part of my job, so I have and always
will make an effort to improve and do well when doing it. Just keep the mind
clear and keep writing with the inner critic in mind. He loves to mess with
you, but you have to remember his presence and be one with your writing.
John’s Mind (First thought piece
done… not too bad in my opinion… but inner critic thinks paragraph two needs
some work… screw him... I’ll leave it… hopefully I’ll get a
good grade… alright time for my next class… J-Lauer out.)
J-Lauer, where do I start? I think I laughed more over this piece than I've laughed in a week! Not laughed AT it, mind you, but I enjoyed your voice and tone here, and especially the inclusion of the "John's Mind" at the end. What great idea to include the inner critic! Later on in the course when we talk about reflection, you'll be right at home, because you're already reflecting.
ReplyDeleteSo, little secret here: though I take my work and my students' efforts very seriously, I can't live without some sarcasm and I think discussions should be fun. What we have here is (not a failure to communicate, though you should hear this in that voice http://youtu.be/V2f-MZ2HRHQ), a class full of smart-asses, who have just the right amount of spunk and smarts to make a semester a blast!
You know what I would like to develop in this course, since we have so many engineers and others who like direct writing, and me who is going to insist on teaching you SOMETHING about the merits of academic writing? I'd like to have a routine, friendly banter. When some assignment or paper sounds ridiculously long and unreasonable, I'd like to hear, "Alright, the way an engineer would write this is..." and we can all learn through friendly debate.....